This award is for the creation of the best male character in fanfic. Who did you fall in love with, who did you hate with all your heart? Who did you wish was your friend in real life? The story in which the character is found must be done, unfinished stories will be rewarded next year!

And the nominees are:

Author and story
Character
Nominator and motivation

Becca

What Might Have Been

at Ponnyexpressen and
The Hitching Post

JON

Aimee
Jon was the perfect example of what Lou's son should be! He was absolutely precious, making you just fall in love with him!

Sid McCabe

My foolish heart

at Ponnyexpressen

Rafferty

Katta
He's the perfect Byronite hero: bad but good, dangerous but loving, and soooo cool. Also, since I'm fond of using quotes in every possible situation, I can totally relate to him.

Lily Shannon
First off, Rafferty was a sexy, sexy man. He had that dangerous, bad boy quality and yet he quoted Shakespeare and Emily Dickinson! He was funny and interesting (he robbed stagecoaches for the heck of it!) and romantic at heart. I loved how he fell for Lou and how it brought out another side of him. I can completely understand Lou falling for someone like Rafferty, even as much as I love the Kid and Jimmy. Rafferty was a great character and I really wish we had seen him on the show!

Lisa R

Secrets of the night

at The Kidnation and the FanFicList

Jackson

Beth
I thought the portrayal of Jackson as Kid's son was very believable. His character had the same shyness, reserve, and determination of his father. The same quiet dignity that made you feel for him and wish for Lou to hurry up and accept him into her heart fully.

Connie

Alter Ego

at Ponnyexpressen and on The FanFicList

Joe Jacobs

Lisa R
It's rare to think of nominating the bad guy for an award, you always want the good guy to win, but Connie wrote Joe Jacobs as the dastardly villain so well, how could I not nominate him. From moment one I knew Joe was going to be a character that I was going to loath. He raped and murdered an innocent girl, plotted against his twin, kidnapped him, and tried to assume his life with in the Express and with Lou and that's just going to far. Connie made it easy for the reader to hate Joe and I guess that's what makes her a good author, if she hadn't been so harsh with his character, I do not think the story would have been as effectual. It's a shame she had to kill him off - it would be interesting to see him in a sequel. (Then again, the riders did leave before the hanging…)

Raydeen

The New Man in Town II

at Ponnyexpressen, and on The FanFicList

Jordan McInnerny

Charla
This isn't a male character that leaves you with any affection, but you certainly love to hate him. He
leaves a lasting impression on the reader, and that is undeniable. He's a well-written villain straight from Raye's imagination.

Lisa R

Honor Thy Father


at The Kidnation and The FanFicList

Ethan Wicks

Beth
I hate Wicks, as I'm sure everyone does. However, I feel that this category is not just for the good guys, but for the bad guys as well. Lisa did a marvelous job making me hate Wicks even more. He was a great villain, the man you love to hate, and Lisa really elaborated on the character introduced to us in the show and turned him into a real sick devil with a mind almost too twisted to fathom. Every good story needs a good villain, and Ethan Wicks is perfect in that role

Sid

The Streets of London

at Ponnyexpressen

Julian Arthur Westward
Lisa R
Bastard. There's no other word to adequately describe this character. Through phenomenal descriptions and actions, he came across as the devil he was meant to be and as his crimes unfolded it was easy to begin to hate him even more. Yet, just when you think Julian Westward had peaked as an amoral son-of-a-bitch, he goes and not only kills Nan, but also has the audacity to brag about it afterwards to Jimmy! Julian deserved every punch he got from Jimmy when he was escorted to the jail and every year he received in prison for his crimes. Sid's depiction of this man who thought himself "King of the World" was amazing. He would win for best villain hands down, but for now he'll remain in the male character category. This character belongs in a true novel and I hope one day Sid plagiarizes herself and uses him.